Measured: Closures are named for their mechanism and judged on how completely they shut the opening and how much force they hold against.
The basics
What to know about bag closure
A closure trades speed against security, and no design escapes the trade. A zip that runs the whole opening keeps hands and rain out, and asks for two hands and a few seconds every time you use it. An open top gives you your keys in one motion and protects nothing at all. Everything else sits between those two points.
Judge a closure by how completely it shuts the opening and how much force it resists, not by how it looks when fastened. A magnet holds against gravity but releases the moment the bag tips or a strap catches. A turnlock is mechanically positive, meaning it stays engaged until you rotate it back, so it holds whatever position the bag ends up in. A drawstring leaves a gathered gap at the center that a hand fits through however hard you pull the cord.
Match the closure to where you use the bag. A desk, a car and a familiar office ask almost nothing of it, while crowded transport and unfamiliar cities ask for a full-length zip or a lock. Rain sets the same test. A gathered or open top lets water straight in, and a flap covering a third of the front sheds it.